Campfire Bans Are Not Going Away. A Propane Fire Pit Is How You Still Have a Fire.
Campfire bans across the West have gone from seasonal nuisance to near-permanent reality at many campgrounds. But a CSA-certified propane fire pit is a legal campfire alternative at most parks — you get real flame, real heat, and zero smoke, with none of the wood logistics. Here are the four best options, ranked.
4.6★ · 2,500+ reviews
Push-button start · 58,000 BTU · CSA certified · 6-ft hose
The 870 is the sweet spot. Push-button auto-ignition means no fumbling with a lighter in the dark. 58,000 BTU is genuine heat output — you feel it within seconds. CSA certified means campgrounds and parks that allow propane appliances will accept it. The 6-foot hose gives you enough distance to keep the tank out of the way. If you want one portable fire pit and you want it to just work, this is it.
4.5★ · 3,000+ reviews
Auto-ignition · 58,000 BTU · CSA certified · Includes 10 lb tank + grate + bag
The 893 is what you buy when you want everything in one order: the fire bowl, a 10 lb refillable propane tank, a stainless grate (so you can cook over it), and a carry bag. The auto-ignition is identical to the 870. The bundled 10 lb tank is smaller than a standard barbecue tank but makes the whole kit genuinely portable — lighter to carry camping than hauling a 20 lb cylinder. Best option if you're outfitting from scratch.
4.5★ · 5,000+ reviews
Manual ignition · 58,000 BTU · CSA certified · Most reviews of any model
The 823 is the original. No auto-ignition — you use a long lighter — but otherwise identical BTU output and CSA certification. Over 5,000 reviews at 4.5 stars makes it the most battle-tested propane fire bowl on Amazon. If you don't mind using a lighter and want to save a few dollars, the 823 is the honest best-value pick. The certification that matters for campfire bans is the same across all three Outland models.
4.4★ · 1,200+ reviews
Auto-ignition · 52,000 BTU · ETL certified · 10-ft hose · Lava rocks included
The Camplux is the budget alternative with a few genuine advantages: a 10-foot hose (4 feet longer than Outland's), lava rocks included, and auto-ignition. It's ETL certified rather than CSA — functionally equivalent safety standards, but verify with your specific campground since some explicitly require CSA. At lower BTU (52,000 vs 58,000) you'll notice slightly less heat at max output, but most buyers run these at moderate settings anyway.
Buying Guide: What Actually Matters
BTU Output: What 58,000 Means in Practice
All three Outland models run at 58,000 BTU at maximum output. The Camplux hits 52,000 BTU. For reference, a standard propane grill burner runs 10,000–15,000 BTU per burner — so 58,000 BTU is serious heat. At a 6-foot radius from the bowl, you feel genuine warmth on a cool evening. At 10 feet, it's pleasant but not warm. These fire pits are designed for gathering around, not for heating a large space. Don't expect a patio heater — do expect a real campfire experience without the smoke.
CSA vs. ETL Certification
Both CSA and ETL are nationally recognized testing laboratories. CSA (Canadian Standards Association) and ETL (Intertek) certification both indicate the product meets ANSI Z21.97 — the standard for outdoor decorative gas appliances. From a safety standpoint, they're equivalent. From a campground-policy standpoint, most parks require "CSA certification" specifically because that's what their policy language says — even if ETL-certified products meet the same standard. All Outland models are CSA certified. The Camplux is ETL certified. If your campground has specific language, verify before you go.
The 20 lb Tank vs. 1 lb Canister Trap
Every propane fire pit on this list connects to a standard 20 lb propane tank via a hose — the same tank you use for a gas grill. They do not run on 1 lb Coleman camping canisters without a separate adapter hose purchased additionally. This surprises a lot of buyers. At 58,000 BTU, a 1 lb canister lasts roughly 1 hour at full output — barely enough for one campfire session. A 20 lb tank gives you 4–5 hours at full output or 6–8 hours at moderate settings. The Outland 893 comes with a 10 lb refillable tank, which is a nice middle ground for camping portability.
Manual vs. Auto-Ignition
The Outland 823 and all older Outland models use manual ignition — open the gas valve and touch a long lighter or match to the lava rocks. It works reliably and there's nothing electronic to fail. The 870 and 893 add a push-button piezo igniter. Auto-ignition is genuinely convenient, especially in the dark, in the cold, or when your hands are full. The Camplux also includes auto-ignition. If you've used a gas grill before, you already know how to use manual ignition — it's not a meaningful hardship. But if you want the convenience, pay for the 870.
Bowl Size: 19 Inches Is Standard
All four models here have a 19-inch bowl diameter, which is the standard size for portable propane fire pits. Larger 21-inch models exist but lose some portability. The 19-inch bowl produces a flame approximately 12–14 inches wide with lava rocks and 8–10 inches tall at moderate output — a visible, satisfying fire that reads well at night from across the campsite. For comparison, a typical campfire ring is 24–36 inches — these fire pits produce a smaller, more controlled flame, which is intentional.
Will These Work During a Fire Ban?
In most cases, yes — with the right certification and the right campground. Here's how to confirm before you arrive:
- Check the current fire restriction level for your destination (USFS, BLM, or state park websites post daily updates).
- Call the specific campground and ask: "Are CSA-certified propane fire pits permitted under the current fire restriction?"
- Bring a printed copy of your fire pit's CSA or ETL certification page. Some campground hosts will ask to see it.
- Under the most severe restrictions (some Level 3 bans), all open flames including propane may be prohibited. No fire pit passes that level.
Quick Comparison
| Model | BTU | Auto-Ignition | Certification | Hose Length | Kit Includes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outland 870 | 58,000 | Yes | CSA | 6 ft | Cover |
| Outland 893 | 58,000 | Yes | CSA | 6 ft | 10 lb tank + grate + bag |
| Outland 823 | 58,000 | No | CSA | 6 ft | Cover |
| Camplux | 52,000 | Yes | ETL | 10 ft | Lava rocks |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are portable propane fire pits legal during campfire bans?
CSA-certified and ETL-certified propane fire pits are permitted during most campfire ban levels at campgrounds that allow propane appliances. Always confirm with the specific campground — some ban all open flames including propane under severe restrictions. CSA certification is the key credential to ask about.
How long does a 20 lb propane tank last?
At maximum output (58,000 BTU for Outland models), approximately 4–5 hours. At moderate settings, 6–8 hours. Most campfire sessions are 2–3 hours, so a full tank covers 2–3 evenings at moderate use.
Can I cook food over a propane fire pit?
The Outland 893 includes a cooking grate. Other models can add one. Propane burns clean — no ash or smoke — which makes it cleaner for cooking than a wood fire. A standard 19-inch campfire grate fits all Outland models.
Can I use a propane fire pit on a covered porch or indoors?
No. These are outdoor-only appliances. Propane combustion produces carbon monoxide. Never use in an enclosed or semi-enclosed space. Treat it like a gas grill: outdoors only, with adequate ventilation overhead.
Looking at other fire pit options beyond propane? See our full outdoor fire pit roundup covering wood-burning, smokeless, and propane models compared side-by-side.
Get our best picks in your inbox
No spam. Just honest Amazon reviews, once a week.
Unsubscribe any time. We'll never sell your address.